The story ‘Electric Rioters’ which you read before,
I wrote in Hindi on the demand and concept of a SciFi fan Reema Sarwal. She raised
a question whether a human can be electrified?
After completing the story I received some valuable
comments on my story :
Reema Sarwal’ Comment :
Zeashan ji, Thank you for writing this story on
demand !! As usual, it shows your excellent command over an intriguing setting
and a racy plot that makes for an interesting read !
Um, isn't it strange that the scientist should be
so careless as to be electrocuted by his own slave? But more importantly,
history proves that scientists, however mad, never wish to rule the world -
that's not at all what they want from life - they're happier doing more
research! And in this story, there is no revenge motive either (for the
scientist) to make it sound probable, nor is he doing it for some other
controlling organization.
The story also makes me feel very sad because the
scientist cannot think of any productive use for his invention and such a good
invention too, which could have been so good for the tribe in many other ways
than saving them from the outsiders, and it is then lost to the whole world !
That said, it is still a pretty good story as it
addresses the all-important issue of preserving natural habitats in such a
unique fashion.
Thanks again!
Dr. Arvind Mishra’s Comment :
I must admit that I have an inherent inability to
be non judgemental whether a particular story is good or bad .Reema has indeed
raised certain logical points which I trust shall be suitably addressed by the
writer-but one thing which I appreciate is the writer's ability to accept the
challenge to write a story on a given theme and Zeashan has not dissappointed
us. In Hindi pulp novels there has been a stereotype of a mad scientist
desirous of ruling the world and Zeashan has just followed the trend –
but I APPRECIATE Reema's outlook also which
portrays a scientist as an angel ! ( Being one myself ! ha ha ! ) .Thanks Reema
for having such a nice attitude towards scientists !
The pitfalls apart I like
the Zeashan's specific style the way he makes the plot to have an errie
environment reminding me of the famous Tilism stories of CHANDRKANTAA SANTATI.
No comments:
Post a Comment