A reply by a SciFi fan Ms. Reema Sarwal on the
questions raised by Mr. Swapnil Bhartiya on my story ‘Electric Rioters’. (See
the previous post)
Swapnil ji,
I was completely flabbergasted by your point nos. 3
and 4 !
>>"The movement itself will raise
suspicion among authorities."
I'm amazed at your utopic faith in the authorities!
! They notice NOTHING. I repeat, nothing. They wouldn't notice if you
transported a rocket from Point A in the Himalayas to Point B in Tamil Nadu via
road.
We're talking "authorities" who don't see
entire colonies being built on ground surface in the capital city of Delhi.
What chance do they have, given a millennium, of having a single clue about an
underground laboratory being built below a Tribal temple in the heart of a
jungle? Whatever made you dream of such a thing as land acquisition in this
case?
I'm also not sure what makes you talk of a
"factory" -- I read it as a fairly usual lab, though advanced, with
some computers, 2 human-sized glass capsules, 2 beds, medical equipment, and
some laser machinery -- pretty much humdrum for SF. Besides, our scientist is
employed at a high position in the government, he could easily steal most of
the stuff he needed from his official lab and contacts -- that's something we
obviously expect of him! He's surely not a "normal" govt. employee if
he can't even do that much.
As for point no. 4, to protect urban
"citizens" from "uncivilized" tribals, the orders would be
loud and clear -- shoot to kill. I particularly liked the satire at the
beginning of the story when one cop suggests that the entire tribal community
should be exterminated. That's one of the reasons I said it was a good story--
it captures the attitudes and mindset of our society.
No comments:
Post a Comment